How to Challenge Delay or Denial Tactics by an Insurer After a Car Accident in North Carolina

Woman looking tired next to bills

Detailed Answer

North Carolina law gives injured people strong tools to push back when an auto insurer drags its feet or flat-out refuses to pay a valid claim. Below are the most effective ways to challenge these delay or denial tactics.

1. Know the Rules Insurers Must Follow

The North Carolina Unfair Claims Settlement Practices statute, N.C. Gen. Stat. § 58-63-15(11), lists conduct that is illegal, including:

  • Failing to acknowledge or act on communications within a reasonable time.
  • Refusing to pay a claim without a prompt, reasonable investigation.
  • Offering substantially less than the claim’s value to force a settlement.
  • Delaying payment to influence you to accept a lower offer.

When an insurer violates this statute, you may add a separate claim under the North Carolina Unfair and Deceptive Trade Practices Act (N.C. Gen. Stat. § 75-1.1). If successful, the court can triple your damages and award attorneys’ fees.

2. Build a Complete Evidence File Early

Create a central file containing:

  • Police report (DMV-349).
  • Medical records and billing statements.
  • Photos of the vehicles, the scene, and your injuries.
  • Repair estimates or total-loss valuation.
  • Proof of lost wages.
  • All written or recorded communications with the adjuster.

A well-documented claim removes easy excuses for delay and strengthens your position if litigation becomes necessary.

3. Send a Time-Limited Demand Letter

North Carolina does not require a formal demand to trigger bad-faith penalties, but a clear, time-limited demand letter does three things:

  1. Spells out why liability is clear and itemizes your damages.
  2. Sets a reasonable response deadline (usually 30 days).
  3. Warns that you will pursue claims under §§ 58-63-15(11) and 75-1.1 if the insurer fails to respond in good faith.

If the company ignores the deadline or lowballs you without justification, you have created a paper trail that supports a later lawsuit.

4. File a Complaint with the N.C. Department of Insurance (NCDOI)

The Consumer Services Division investigates unfair claim practices. Submit your evidence online or by mail. An inquiry from the NCDOI often prompts faster action because the insurer must reply to the regulator—usually within 15–20 days.

5. Initiate a Bad-Faith or Contract Lawsuit

If delays continue, you may sue in Superior Court for:

  • Breach of Contract – to recover what the policy owes.
  • Bad Faith – when the refusal is “not based on honest disagreement” and is accompanied by aggravating conduct. This can open the door to punitive damages under N.C. Gen. Stat. § 1D-15.
  • Unfair & Deceptive Trade Practices – seeking treble damages and attorney fees under § 75-1.1.

Litigation also stops the three-year negligence statute of limitations (N.C. Gen. Stat. § 1-52) from expiring while you battle the insurer.

6. Recover Pre-Judgment Interest

Under N.C. Gen. Stat. § 24-5(b), you may receive interest on your medical expenses from the date the lawsuit is filed until judgment, reducing the benefit an insurer gains by stalling.

7. Consider Mediation or Arbitration

Even after filing suit, North Carolina courts usually order mediation. A neutral mediator pushes the insurer to explain its position and can lead to a fair settlement without waiting for trial.

Helpful Hints

  • Document every phone call. Note the date, time, and representative’s name.
  • Communicate in writing whenever possible to create a clear record.
  • Respond promptly to requests for information; do not give the insurer ammunition to blame you for delay.
  • Never give a recorded statement without legal advice—it can be used to deny your claim.
  • Preserve social media posts: insurers monitor them for reasons to deny claims.
  • Track all out-of-pocket expenses in a spreadsheet; small costs add up.
  • Consult an attorney early. Insurers recognize when a claimant has professional representation and often adjust their tactics.

Bottom line: North Carolina law does not tolerate bad-faith claim handling. By gathering solid evidence, using time-limited demands, involving regulators, and filing suit when necessary, you can overcome delay or denial tactics and pursue full compensation.

Need help fighting an insurer? Our firm’s personal injury attorneys know the playbook and how to counter it. Call us today at 919-313-2737 for a free consultation and case evaluation.

Categories: 
close-link