How to follow up effectively with an insurance company after submitting additional medical evidence to support my personal injury claim in North Carolina

Woman looking tired next to bills

Detailed Answer

Submitting new medical bills, treatment records, or an updated doctor’s report can strengthen your personal injury claim, but even solid evidence will not move your case forward unless the insurance adjuster reviews it promptly. Below is a step-by-step follow-up plan that complies with North Carolina law and keeps your claim on track.

1. Confirm Receipt in Writing

Within two business days of sending the additional evidence, mail and email a brief confirmation letter. State the date you sent the records, list each document, and ask the adjuster to acknowledge receipt by a specific date. North Carolina’s N.C. Gen. Stat. § 58-63-15(11) classifies the failure to acknowledge communications about a claim within 30 days as an unfair claims practice, so putting the request in writing preserves your rights.

2. Ask for an Updated Timeline

North Carolina does not impose a fixed deadline for insurers to decide every personal injury claim, but § 58-63-15(11) requires “prompt investigation” and “equitable settlement.” Politely request the adjuster’s estimated review timeframe and note it on your calendar.

3. Keep All Follow-Ups Short and Documented

• If the adjuster does not respond by the promised date, call once and leave a voicemail.
• Immediately follow the call with a brief email memorializing the attempt.
• Send certified mail if you have no reply within seven additional days. Include copies of previous correspondence.

4. Leverage Your Medical Evidence

When the adjuster responds, highlight how the new records show:

  • Causal link between the accident and treatment;
  • Permanent impairment ratings under the American Medical Association guidelines;
  • Future care recommendations and projected costs.

Attach an updated demand package if the new evidence increases your economic or non-economic damages.

5. Escalate If Necessary

If your claim stalls past 60 days after submission of the new evidence and you receive no substantive response:

  1. Send a final “good-faith settlement” letter citing § 58-63-15(11) and giving the carrier 10 days to respond.
  2. File a complaint with the North Carolina Department of Insurance.
  3. Consult a North Carolina personal injury attorney to discuss filing suit under the three-year statute of limitations (N.C. Gen. Stat. § 1-52(16)).

6. Stay Professional

Adjusters note tone. Calm, courteous communication preserves your credibility and positions you favorably if litigation becomes necessary.

Helpful Hints

  • Create a claim diary. Log every phone call, email, and letter with dates and names.
  • Use certified mail, return receipt requested for critical documents.
  • Avoid social media posts about your injuries; insurers monitor them.
  • Group medical bills and records chronologically and label each clearly.
  • Set calendar reminders one week before each follow-up deadline.

Need help moving your North Carolina injury claim forward? Our attorneys have years of experience negotiating with insurers and protecting clients’ rights. Call us today at 919-313-2737 for a free, no-obligation consultation.

Categories: 
close-link