How Can Someone Seek Damages From Multiple At-Fault Parties When a Shared Policy Limit Leaves Expenses Unpaid?

Woman looking tired next to bills

How to Recover Damages When Multiple At-Fault Parties Share a Limited Insurance Policy in North Carolina

Quick Answer

North Carolina lets you sue every at-fault party, even when they share a single liability policy that will not cover all of your losses. You may collect the unpaid balance by (1) pursuing each defendant under North Carolina’s joint-and-several liability rules, (2) uncovering any additional insurance (personal, commercial, or umbrella), and (3) tapping your own underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage. Below is a step-by-step explanation.

Detailed Answer

1. Understand Joint-and-Several Liability

If two or more defendants act together to cause one injury, North Carolina common law makes each of them responsible for all of the damages. You are free to:

  • Sue all tortfeasors in the same lawsuit, or
  • Obtain a judgment against just one and collect the entire amount from that defendant.

The paying defendant may seek reimbursement from the others through North Carolina’s Contribution Among Tort-feasors Act, N.C. Gen. Stat. Chapter 1B. Your recovery is not limited by the size of a single insurance policy.

2. Identify Every Possible Policy

Even when defendants share a split-limit auto policy (for example, $100,000 per crash), you may still locate other coverage:

  1. Separate personal policies. A negligent driver might have a personal auto policy that sits on top of the owner’s policy.
  2. Employer or business coverage. If the driver was working, the employer’s commercial auto or general liability policy may apply.
  3. Homeowners or umbrella policies. Umbrella limits often start at $1 million and cover negligent acts, including auto crashes.
  4. Dram-shop or negligent entrustment policies. Bars, restaurants, or vehicle owners sometimes carry separate liability insurance.

Send written notice of your claim to every potential insurer quickly. Delays can jeopardize coverage.

3. Use Your Own Underinsured Motorist (UIM) Coverage

North Carolina requires insurers to offer UIM coverage on auto policies with liability limits above $30,000. Under N.C. Gen. Stat. § 20-279.21(b)(4), you may “stack” UIM limits on up to three vehicles to fill the gap between the at-fault parties’ insurance and your total damages.

Example: Defendants share a $100,000 policy. Your injuries are worth $250,000. If you have $100,000 of UIM on two family cars, you can stack those limits and potentially collect the remaining $150,000 from your own carrier—after meeting statutory notice requirements.

4. Preserve Subrogation and Lien Rights

Health insurers, Medicaid, Medicare, and workers’ compensation carriers may claim part of your settlement. Negotiating those liens increases the net funds available to you and should begin as soon as liability coverage appears insufficient.

5. File Suit Before the Deadline

Most personal-injury claims in North Carolina have a three-year statute of limitations (N.C. Gen. Stat. § 1-52(16)). Filing tolls the deadline and permits discovery to uncover hidden policies or assets.

6. Collect From Personal Assets If Necessary

After exhausting insurance, you may levy bank accounts, garnish wages, or attach property belonging to any defendant who has non-exempt assets. While collection from individuals can be difficult, it remains a viable option when damages are high.

Hypothetical Scenario

A delivery driver (Driver A) rear-ends you while using a borrowed van owned by Friend B. Both individuals are named on the same $100,000 liability policy. Your medical bills and lost wages total $220,000.

  • You sue Driver A, Friend B, and the delivery company in Wake County Superior Court.
  • The company’s $1 million commercial auto policy applies because Driver A was on the clock.
  • Friend B has a $500,000 personal umbrella policy.
  • You accept policy-limit tenders of $100,000 (shared auto policy) and $120,000 (partial payment from the commercial policy) and then file a UIM claim for the remaining $0—your damages are fully paid without touching your own UIM.

Helpful Hints

  • Gather crash reports, witness names, and photographs early—proof of fault supports access to multiple policies.
  • Send written preservation letters to every potential defendant to prevent loss of evidence.
  • Request certified policy declarations pages during discovery.
  • Notify your UIM carrier in writing before accepting any liability-policy tenders to keep UIM coverage intact.
  • Track all medical expenses and wage losses in a spreadsheet; clear documentation speeds settlement and lien reduction.

Conclusion & Call to Action

When a single insurance policy does not cover your losses, North Carolina law allows multiple pathways to full compensation: sue every at-fault party, locate all available coverage, and leverage joint-and-several liability plus UIM stacking. The process is fact-intensive and deadline-driven, so swift legal guidance is critical.

Our firm has years of experience holding multiple defendants accountable and uncovering hidden insurance. If a policy limit offer will not cover your bills, call us today at 919-313-2737 for a free, no-obligation case review.

Categories: 
close-link