How can I challenge my insurer’s refusal to pay my medical bills after a car accident?: Practical steps under North Carolina law

Woman looking tired next to bills

How can I challenge my insurer’s refusal to pay my medical bills after a car accident? - North Carolina

Short Answer

In North Carolina, start by confirming what coverage you’re asking to use: medical payments (med-pay) under your own policy versus the at‑fault driver’s liability coverage. Liability insurers usually pay in one lump sum at settlement, not bill‑by‑bill. If your own insurer denied med‑pay based on limits or another reason, you can appeal in writing with supporting records, file a complaint with the N.C. Department of Insurance, and, if needed, sue for breach of contract and unfair claims practices. Preserve any underinsured motorist (UIM) rights before signing a release.

Understanding the Problem

In North Carolina, can you make your auto insurer pay your accident‑related medical bills now, or challenge a refusal, when you were a back‑seat passenger who treated at an ER, a clinic, and a chiropractor? This turns on which policy you’re claiming under, what the policy limits are, and the timing of payments. Liability carriers generally resolve claims by settlement at the end; med‑pay can reimburse earlier, up to its limits.

Apply the Law

North Carolina distinguishes between first‑party med‑pay benefits (your policy or the host vehicle’s policy) and third‑party liability payments (the at‑fault driver’s insurer). Liability carriers are not obligated to pay medical bills as they come in; they typically pay once, at settlement or judgment. Med‑pay, if purchased, pays reasonable and necessary medical expenses from a crash regardless of fault, up to stated limits. If an insurer denies med‑pay or delays unreasonably, you may challenge the denial through internal appeal, an administrative complaint, and, if necessary, civil litigation for contract breach and unfair claim settlement practices. If UIM coverage may apply, you must obtain your UIM carrier’s written consent before releasing the at‑fault driver to preserve UIM benefits.

Key Requirements

  • Identify the coverage: Confirm whether you’re seeking med‑pay from your policy/household or the host vehicle, or making a liability claim against the at‑fault driver.
  • Understand limits and timing: Med‑pay has dollar caps and pays early if supported; liability insurers usually pay only once, at settlement.
  • Document and demand: Send a written demand with the denial letter, policy pages, medical records/bills, and a concise rebuttal of the stated reason.
  • Preserve UIM rights: Get written consent from your UIM insurer before signing any release of the at‑fault driver.
  • Escalate appropriately: File a complaint with the N.C. Department of Insurance for claim‑handling issues; consider suit for breach of contract and unfair/deceptive practices if warranted.
  • Resolve liens before disbursement: Healthcare liens and reimbursements must be addressed before your lawyer can disburse settlement funds.

What the Statutes Say

Analysis

Apply the Rule to the Facts: You were a passenger with ER, clinic, and chiropractic treatment. If the denial is from med‑pay citing a policy minimum, that often means the med‑pay limit has been reached; you can still pursue the at‑fault driver’s liability coverage (and your UIM if needed). If the denial is from the liability carrier, they typically do not pay bills piecemeal; your attorney’s lump‑sum settlement and release are the standard path. Your lawyer’s lien review is expected in North Carolina before disbursement; it can increase your net recovery.

Process & Timing

  1. Who files: You or your attorney. Where: Your insurer’s claims department (first‑party med‑pay) and/or the at‑fault insurer (liability). For complaints, the North Carolina Department of Insurance. For litigation, the Superior Court in the county where the crash occurred or where the defendant resides. What: A written demand/appeal letter with policy, denial, medical records, and bills; if UIM may apply, a written request for UIM consent to settle; NCDOI online complaint form. When: Send your written appeal promptly after denial; obtain UIM consent before signing any release; statutory litigation deadlines apply (UDTP generally four years; other deadlines can be shorter).
  2. Await the insurer’s reconsideration. If claim‑handling seems unfair or unreasonably delayed, file a complaint with the N.C. Department of Insurance (online portal) while continuing to negotiate.
  3. If the denial persists, file suit for breach of contract (med‑pay) and, when the facts support it, unfair/deceptive practices based on unfair claim settlement conduct. After settlement, your attorney resolves valid liens and then disburses your net recovery.

Exceptions & Pitfalls

  • Med‑pay is optional and limited; once limits are exhausted, no further med‑pay is available even if bills remain.
  • Stacking: You may have med‑pay on multiple household vehicles; confirm all policies before accepting a denial.
  • UIM protection: Failing to get UIM consent before settling with the at‑fault insurer can waive UIM coverage.
  • Release scope: Broad releases can extinguish claims you still need; ensure the release matches the settlement terms and preserves UIM rights.
  • Liens and reimbursements: Health insurers, government programs, and providers may assert reimbursement; your lawyer must address these before disbursement.
  • Communication traps: Giving recorded statements or broad authorizations to the liability carrier can harm your claim; route communications through counsel.

Conclusion

To challenge a refusal to pay medical bills after a North Carolina car crash, first confirm the coverage you’re invoking (med‑pay vs. liability). Send a written appeal with proof, escalate to the N.C. Department of Insurance for unfair claim‑handling, and, if necessary, sue for breach of contract and unfair practices. Protect UIM rights by obtaining your UIM insurer’s written consent before you sign any release. Then finalize settlement and resolve liens before funds are disbursed.

Talk to a Personal Injury Attorney

If you’re facing a denied med‑pay claim or a liability insurer refusing to cover your crash‑related medical bills, our firm can help you challenge the decision and protect your UIM rights. Call us today to discuss your options and timelines.

Disclaimer: This article provides general information about North Carolina law based on the single question stated above. It is not legal advice for your specific situation and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws, procedures, and local practice can change and may vary by county. If you have a deadline, act promptly and speak with a licensed North Carolina attorney.

Categories: 
close-link