Property Damage vs. Injury Claims
A low offer based on vehicle value is usually a property damage dispute. That process is separate from any injury claim you may have from the same incident. Keeping them separate matters because paperwork that settles property damage can sometimes be drafted broadly, and you do not want to accidentally sign away other rights.
What to Document
- Your independent appraisal package: The full report (not just the summary page), the appraiser’s credentials, photos, and the valuation method used.
- Comparable vehicles (“comps”): Listings or sales data the appraisal relied on, including mileage, trim, options, and condition adjustments.
- The insurer’s valuation basis: Ask for the written valuation report, the comps they used, and every adjustment they applied (condition, prior damage, mileage, options, title history, etc.).
- Condition evidence: Pre-loss photos, maintenance records, and any documentation showing upgrades or recent major work (if relevant).
- Repair/total loss paperwork (if applicable): Estimates, supplements, invoices, and any “total loss” valuation worksheets.
- Out-of-pocket costs tied to the dispute: Towing, storage, and temporary transportation receipts (if relevant).
Common Resolution Paths
-
Negotiation:
Start by narrowing the disagreement to specific line items. Many “low offers” come from disputed assumptions—like condition ratings, missing options, wrong trim level, or comps that do not match your vehicle. A focused, written rebuttal that corrects those inputs often moves the number more than repeating the bottom-line appraisal figure.
Also consider requesting that the insurer promptly explain the basis for its offer in relation to the policy and the facts. In North Carolina, unfair claim-settlement rules generally require insurers to provide a reasonable explanation for a denial or compromise offer when requested, and that request can help “lock in” what the insurer is relying on.
-
Appraisal/dispute processes:
If your policy has an appraisal clause, it is commonly used when both sides agree there is a covered loss but disagree on the amount of loss/value. While the exact steps depend on the policy language, the usual structure is: each side selects an appraiser; the appraisers try to agree; if they cannot, an umpire is used to resolve the value dispute.
Appraisal can be a practical tool when negotiations stall, but it is not a cure-all. It typically addresses value, not broader issues like coverage defenses, causation disputes, or unrelated delays. Your attorney can help confirm whether the dispute is truly an “amount of loss” issue and whether invoking appraisal makes strategic sense in your situation.
-
Small claims or court options:
If the dispute cannot be resolved through negotiation or appraisal, litigation may be an option in some cases. The right forum and the best strategy depend on the claim type (first-party vs. third-party), the amounts at issue, and the evidence available. Court also comes with rules, deadlines, and costs that should be weighed carefully before filing.
How This Applies
Apply to your facts: You already did an important thing by getting an independent appraisal, and you also documented that direct negotiations did not resolve the gap. The next practical step is to demand the insurer’s written valuation basis (their comps and adjustments) and respond point-by-point using your appraiser’s support. If the disagreement is purely about value and your policy allows it, invoking the appraisal clause may be a structured way to force a decision on the amount of loss—without relying on informal back-and-forth.
What the Statutes Say (Optional)
- N.C. Gen. Stat. § 1-540.2 – A property-damage settlement from a motor vehicle collision does not automatically release other claims unless the written settlement terms clearly say so.
Conclusion
When an insurer’s offer is far below a credible independent appraisal, the goal is to turn the disagreement into a documented, item-by-item valuation dispute. Get the insurer’s valuation report and comps, correct any wrong inputs, and keep everything in writing. If negotiations stay stuck and the issue is truly the amount of loss, the policy’s appraisal clause may provide a structured path to resolve value. One next step: gather the insurer’s valuation documents and your appraisal support into one packet for a focused written challenge.
