How do I figure out which trucking company and insurance policy actually covers the truck that hit me when the police report lists different companies?

Woman looking tired next to bills

How do I figure out which trucking company and insurance policy actually covers the truck that hit me when the police report lists different companies? - North Carolina

Short Answer

In North Carolina, it is common for a commercial truck to be connected to more than one company (the truck owner, the motor carrier operating under a USDOT number, and sometimes a broker or shipper). When the police report lists multiple names, the most reliable way to identify the responsible trucking company and the correct insurance is to match the truck’s identifiers (USDOT number, license plate/VIN, and driver/employer records) and then confirm coverage through written requests and, if needed, a lawsuit with formal discovery and subpoenas.

Understanding the Problem

If you were hit in North Carolina by a commercial truck and the crash report lists more than one company name, you are likely asking which company is legally responsible and which insurance policy must respond, especially where the insurer says the vehicle or driver may not be listed while coverage counsel reviews the claim.

Apply the Law

Under North Carolina law, law enforcement prepares a written crash report and that report is generally available as a public record, but it is not a final legal decision about which business is responsible or which insurance policy applies. Commercial trucking also involves layered relationships (owner-operator arrangements, leased equipment, and carriers operating under regulatory authority), so the “name on the door” or a name typed into the report may not match the motor carrier that legally controlled the trip.

North Carolina also requires certain for-hire motor carriers to verify insurance for the vehicles they operate in the state, which can help confirm whether a carrier should have coverage in place for a particular truck and operation. If the insurer disputes coverage, the practical way to force clarity is to identify the correct motor carrier and any other potentially responsible parties, then use written demands and (if necessary) court-issued discovery tools to obtain the actual insurance agreements and trip documents.

Key Requirements

  • Identify the motor carrier for the trip: Determine which company’s operating authority (often tied to a USDOT number) was being used when the crash happened.
  • Match the vehicle precisely: Confirm the correct tractor and trailer by VIN and plate, not just a company name or logo.
  • Confirm the driver’s work relationship: A driver can be an employee of one company while driving equipment owned by another and dispatched by a third.
  • Confirm insurance tied to the operation: Coverage can depend on whether the truck was being operated “for-hire,” under a lease, or under a particular carrier’s authority.
  • Use formal tools if voluntary cooperation stalls: If the carrier/insurer will not confirm coverage, a lawsuit allows subpoenas and document requests to compel the records that answer the question.

What the Statutes Say

Analysis

Apply the Rule to the Facts: Here, the police report lists multiple company names, which often happens when the officer records a door logo, a registered owner name, and a separate carrier name tied to the trip. Because the insurer says the policy may not list the vehicle or driver and coverage counsel is reviewing, you should assume the “right” policy may be tied to a different entity than the one you first contacted. The practical goal is to lock down the correct motor carrier/owner relationship for that specific trip and then obtain the actual policy and endorsements that apply to that carrier and vehicle.

Process & Timing

  1. Who requests records: The injured person (or their attorney). Where: The law enforcement agency that investigated and/or the North Carolina Division of Motor Vehicles for the officer’s crash report. What: Request the officer’s crash report and any supplemental pages; confirm the tractor and trailer VIN/plate and any listed USDOT/ICC/MC information. When: As soon as possible after the crash, especially before sending a final demand package.
  2. Confirm the “identity chain” in writing: Send written requests (not just phone calls) to each listed company and any known insurer asking them to confirm (a) who owned the tractor/trailer, (b) who employed the driver, (c) which motor carrier’s authority the truck was operating under, and (d) the liability insurer(s) and policy number(s) for that trip. Ask them to preserve key records (dispatch/trip documents, lease agreements, driver qualification file, and maintenance/inspection records) because those documents often show which company controlled the trip.
  3. If they won’t confirm, use court tools: If coverage remains “under review” and the companies point fingers, filing a lawsuit is often the step that allows subpoenas to insurers, brokers, and third parties and document requests to the trucking entities to obtain the controlling lease/trip paperwork and the actual insurance agreements.

Exceptions & Pitfalls

  • “Name on the truck” confusion: A logo or trade name on the cab may be different from the legal entity that employed the driver or the carrier operating under the USDOT number for that trip.
  • Owner-operator and lease arrangements: The truck may be owned by one company/individual but leased to and dispatched by another, which can change which policy applies.
  • Tractor vs. trailer coverage gaps: A claim can involve separate policies for the tractor and trailer; focusing on only one can delay identifying all available coverage.
  • Relying on the crash report as “final”: The crash report is important, but it is not a binding determination of the responsible company or the correct insurer.
  • Waiting for “coverage counsel” too long: Coverage review can take time, but you still need to protect deadlines and preserve evidence; sometimes the only way to get a clear answer is formal discovery after filing suit.

Conclusion

When a North Carolina crash report lists different trucking-related companies, the correct answer usually comes from matching the truck’s identifiers (VIN/plate and any USDOT information) to the motor carrier that controlled the trip and then confirming the actual liability insurance tied to that operation. If the insurer says the vehicle or driver may not be listed and coverage is under review, your next step is to send written requests to each listed company and insurer to confirm the responsible carrier and policy and to preserve trip and lease records.

Talk to a Personal Injury Attorney

If you’re dealing with a truck crash where multiple company names appear and the insurer is questioning coverage, our firm has experienced attorneys who can help you identify the responsible parties, request the right records, and keep the claim moving on a realistic timeline. Reach out today. Call {{CONTACT NUMBER}}.

Disclaimer: This article provides general information about North Carolina law based on the single question stated above. It is not legal advice for your specific situation and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws, procedures, and local practice can change and may vary by county. If you have a deadline, act promptly and speak with a licensed North Carolina attorney.

Categories: 
close-link