Accident Q&A series

Can an insurance company deny my claim if it believes I was partly at fault?

· Wallace Pierce Law

Questions about your claim? Talk directly with a North Carolina injury attorney. Call (919) 313-2737 Send your details

Short Answer

Yes. An insurance company may deny a North Carolina personal injury claim if it concludes that your own negligence helped cause the accident or injury. North Carolina’s contributory negligence rule can create a complete defense rather than merely reducing payment by a percentage, but the insurer’s decision is not automatically the final legal answer. The evidence, the reason for the denial, and any filing deadline should be reviewed carefully.

Why Partial Fault Can Lead to a Denial in North Carolina

North Carolina follows a contributory negligence rule. In an ordinary negligence claim, the injured person generally must show that another party failed to use reasonable care and that this failure caused the injury. The other party or its insurer may respond by claiming that the injured person also failed to use reasonable care.

If the defense proves that your own negligence helped cause the injury, it can prevent recovery. This differs from the comparative-fault systems used in many states, where an injured person’s compensation may be reduced according to a percentage of fault.

Not every mistake or questionable decision establishes contributory negligence. The alleged conduct must qualify as negligence and must have contributed to the injury. A denial letter stating that you were “partly at fault” does not, by itself, prove those points.

Under N.C. Gen. Stat. § 1-139, the party raising contributory negligence generally has the burden of proving that defense. Evidence should therefore address both what the other party did wrong and why your own actions were reasonable under the circumstances.

An Insurer’s Liability Decision Is Not a Court Ruling

An adjuster may make a liability decision after reviewing statements, photographs, reports, records, and information from the insured person. The insurer may deny the claim, assign blame to you, or make a compromise offer while continuing to dispute fault.

That position can be challenged. Depending on the facts, a response may identify missing evidence, correct an inaccurate description of the event, address an inconsistent witness statement, or explain why the conduct blamed on you did not cause the injury.

It is usually helpful to ask for the denial or liability position in writing. The explanation may reveal whether the dispute concerns what happened, whether someone acted negligently, whether that conduct caused the event, or whether the insurer questions the connection between the event and the claimed injuries.

Evidence That May Matter in a Partial-Fault Dispute

Contributory negligence disputes are often fact-sensitive. Preserve available information before recordings are overwritten, physical conditions change, or witnesses become difficult to locate.

Potentially useful materials include:

  • The insurer’s denial letter and written explanation of its liability decision.
  • Photographs or video showing the location, surrounding conditions, property damage, or other relevant details.
  • Incident, crash, or law-enforcement reports, if any exist.
  • Names and contact information for witnesses.
  • Messages, emails, claim letters, and notes from conversations with adjusters.
  • Any recorded or written statements previously given to an insurer.
  • Medical records, bills, and visit summaries documenting the claimed injuries.
  • Proof of lost income or other documented financial losses, when relevant.
  • A copy of any settlement offer, release, or other document the insurer asks you to sign.

Evidence should be preserved in its original form when possible. Avoid editing photographs, discarding damaged property, or posting detailed accounts of the event on social media. Statements made soon after an accident can be compared with later evidence, so accuracy matters.

What a Compromise Offer Means

An insurer can make a settlement offer without accepting fault. A compromise offer may reflect the insurer’s evaluation of risk, litigation expense, disputed evidence, or other claim considerations. The offer does not necessarily mean that the insurer has withdrawn its contributory negligence position.

You do not have to treat the first offer as the insurer’s final position. A supported response may address the liability dispute and provide organized documentation of injuries and losses. If an attorney is handling the matter, the client decides whether to settle and may authorize negotiations within defined limits. The attorney can communicate with the adjuster and negotiate within that authority, but an offer below the client’s authorized minimum should not be accepted without further client approval.

Before resolving the claim, review the proposed release carefully. A signed release commonly ends the claims identified in that document, even if additional losses or complications later become apparent. The exact language and the circumstances matter.

Practical Steps After a Partial-Fault Denial

  1. Request the insurer’s reasoning. Ask for a written explanation identifying the conduct it believes was negligent and how that conduct allegedly contributed to the injury.
  2. Preserve relevant evidence. Save reports, photographs, video, witness details, correspondence, records, and financial documentation.
  3. Check the insurer’s factual assumptions. Look for missing facts, unsupported conclusions, or statements that conflict with objective evidence.
  4. Be careful with additional statements. A request for a detailed recorded statement may affect the fault dispute. Make sure any information you provide is accurate, and do not guess about facts you do not remember.
  5. Review settlement paperwork before signing. An offer may require a broad release of claims even though the insurer continues to deny responsibility.
  6. Track the legal deadline. Negotiations and claim discussions do not automatically extend the time for filing a lawsuit.

N.C. Gen. Stat. § 1-52 provides a three-year filing period for many North Carolina personal injury actions, but a different deadline may apply depending on the claim and the parties involved. An insurer’s open file, compromise offer, or ongoing negotiation generally should not be treated as an agreement to extend the filing period.

How This Applies to the Stated Claim

Here, the insurer disputed liability based on North Carolina’s contributory negligence rule but also made a compromise offer without accepting fault. Those positions are not necessarily inconsistent. The insurer may continue arguing that the claim could be barred while offering money to resolve the uncertainty.

The attorney may negotiate for an improved offer within the authority provided by the client. The response should focus on the evidence concerning fault, causation, injuries, and documented losses rather than assuming that the compromise offer amounts to an admission. Any final release and the applicable lawsuit deadline also need attention before the claim is resolved.

When Wallace Pierce Law May Be Able to Help

Wallace Pierce Law may be able to review the insurer’s stated reasons for denying a Durham injury claim, identify the evidence relevant to contributory negligence, and communicate the client’s position to the adjuster. The firm can also help organize medical and financial documentation, evaluate a compromise offer, monitor applicable deadlines, and review settlement language.

No attorney can promise that an insurer will withdraw a denial or increase an offer. The available options depend on the evidence, the conduct attributed to each person, insurance issues, damages documentation, and the time remaining to pursue the claim.

A path forward

What happened is part of your story. Not the end of it.

A clear plan makes room to heal. We handle the claim. You get back to your life.

Talk through what comes next