Short Answer
Yes. You can generally continue negotiating while stating that your current settlement demand remains open, but the wording and any expiration date matter. To prevent confusion, your attorney should confirm in writing that discussions do not withdraw, replace, reduce, or extend the pending demand unless expressly stated. Remember that the insurer’s review is not an acceptance, and ongoing negotiations do not automatically extend a North Carolina lawsuit deadline.
Keeping the Existing Demand Open During Negotiations
A settlement demand communicates the terms on which you are presently willing to resolve an injury claim. Remaining open to discussion does not necessarily mean that you have withdrawn that demand or agreed to accept less.
However, informal emails, telephone conversations, and new settlement figures can create uncertainty. An insurer might interpret a later communication as a replacement demand, an extension, or a different proposal. The safest approach is to make the claimant’s position clear in writing.
For example, an attorney may explain that the existing demand remains pending under its original terms while the claimant is willing to consider additional proposals. The communication should also state whether the original deadline remains in effect. This preserves a clear record without suggesting that the insurer’s earlier offer has become acceptable.
What the Insurer’s Higher-Level Review Means
When a claims representative sends a demand to a supervisor, committee, or other decision-maker, it usually means the representative needs more settlement authority or further evaluation. It does not mean the insurer has accepted the demand.
Higher-level review may lead to several possible responses:
- The insurer may accept the demand according to its stated terms.
- It may make another offer below the demand.
- It may request records, bills, wage-loss documents, or other supporting material.
- It may reject the demand or maintain its prior position.
- It may ask for additional time to complete its review.
If the insurer requests more time, the response should be documented. Any extension should identify the new deadline and clarify whether all other terms remain unchanged. Silence about an extension can lead to disagreement over whether the original demand expired.
Review the Demand’s Exact Terms Before Continuing
Before sending another message, your attorney should review the current demand as a whole. Important details include:
- Expiration language: Determine whether the demand has a firm deadline or remains open without a stated end date.
- Method of acceptance: Some demands require written acceptance, delivery of payment, proof of policy limits, or satisfaction of other stated conditions.
- Scope of the proposed release: The demand may specify which person, company, claim, or insurance coverage would be released.
- Supporting evidence: Confirm that the insurer has the records needed to evaluate fault, injuries, medical expenses, lost income, and other claimed losses.
- Other coverage: Consider whether accepting a proposal could affect claims involving additional liability coverage or uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage.
Demand terms should be precise because an insurer may attempt to accept them. Depending on the language and the communications between the parties, an enforceable settlement may arise before a check is issued or a formal release is signed. A claimant represented by counsel should therefore coordinate settlement communications through that attorney rather than sending separate messages to the adjuster.
How to Avoid Accidentally Changing Your Position
Clear written communication is important during settlement negotiations. A message can state that the pending demand remains open and that discussing other figures is not intended to withdraw or modify it. If a new number is proposed, the attorney should clarify whether it is a separate alternative, a replacement demand, or only part of a preliminary discussion.
It may also help to keep a negotiation file containing:
- The original demand and all supporting attachments.
- Proof showing when and how the insurer received it.
- The insurer’s offers and written responses.
- Emails confirming telephone conversations.
- Requests for additional information or review time.
- Any written extension or revised deadline.
- Current medical bills, records, visit summaries, and income-loss documentation.
If the insurer’s position is unclear, counsel may ask what facts, documents, or evaluation issues support the current offer. That information can help determine whether additional documentation would make further negotiations productive.
Do Not Let Negotiations Obscure the Filing Deadline
Settlement discussions and internal insurance review generally do not stop the applicable filing period. For many North Carolina personal injury actions, N.C. Gen. Stat. § 1-52 provides a three-year limitations period, although the correct deadline depends on the type of claim and the facts.
A demand letter is not a lawsuit. An insurer’s promise to review a claim, request for more records, or continued exchange of settlement figures does not automatically preserve the right to sue. Counsel should track the applicable deadline separately and leave enough time to prepare and file a case if negotiations do not resolve the claim.
How This Applies to the Current Negotiation
Here, the initial offer was rejected and a substantially higher counterdemand was submitted through an attorney. The claims representative has forwarded that demand for higher-level review. Those facts suggest that the current demand can remain the claimant’s stated settlement position while the insurer evaluates whether to increase its authority.
If the claimant remains willing to consider a reasonable negotiated resolution, the attorney can communicate that flexibility without necessarily withdrawing the pending demand. The written message should identify the demand by date and amount, confirm whether its deadline remains unchanged, and explain that no modification is intended unless later confirmed expressly.
The claimant should not assume that higher-level review will produce a particular response. Until the insurer accepts the stated terms or the parties clearly agree on different terms, the claim remains unresolved. Any final proposal should be evaluated carefully for its release language, included parties, payment conditions, possible liens, and effect on other available claims or coverage.
When Wallace Pierce Law May Be Able to Help
Wallace Pierce Law may be able to review the existing demand, the insurer’s offers, applicable deadlines, and the communications surrounding higher-level review. This can include identifying ambiguous language, documenting whether a demand remains open, organizing evidence supporting the requested amount, and evaluating new settlement terms.
The firm may also help determine what information the insurer still needs, communicate through the appropriate claims representative, and review proposed release documents before a settlement is finalized. The appropriate strategy depends on the demand’s wording, the available evidence, insurance coverage, and the time remaining to protect the North Carolina injury claim.