Accident Q&A series

Can the other driver's insurance company take back a rental vehicle because it is disputing fault?

· Wallace Pierce Law

Questions about your claim? Talk directly with a North Carolina injury attorney. Call (919) 313-2737 Send your details

Short Answer

Yes. The other driver’s insurer can usually end its authorization or direct payment for a rental vehicle while it disputes fault. That does not necessarily decide who caused the crash or eliminate a possible claim for reasonable rental expenses, but the renter should confirm the cutoff date and return the vehicle on time unless another payment arrangement is in place.

Why a Fault Dispute Can End Rental Authorization

When the other driver’s insurance company provides a rental, it is normally doing so as part of a third-party property damage claim. The insurer does not have the same contractual relationship with you that your own insurance company may have with its policyholder.

If the insurer decides that liability is unclear, it may pause or terminate voluntary rental payments while it investigates. In practical terms, the insurer usually does not personally take possession of the vehicle. Instead, it tells the rental company that its payment authorization will end on a certain date. The rental company may then require the named renter to return the vehicle or become personally responsible for additional charges under the rental agreement.

Providing a rental at the beginning of a claim also does not necessarily mean that the insurer accepted fault. North Carolina law provides that settling a property damage claim does not, by itself, amount to an admission of liability. N.C. Gen. Stat. § 1-540.2 also explains that resolving property damage does not automatically resolve a separate bodily injury claim unless a properly executed agreement says otherwise.

Who Controls the Rental Vehicle?

The rental company owns the vehicle, and the written rental agreement usually controls who may drive it, when it must be returned, and who owes charges that the insurer does not pay. If the injured person’s child signed the agreement, the child may be the person the rental company treats as financially responsible.

The renter should contact both the adjuster and the rental company promptly. Important questions include:

  • What is the final date and time covered by the insurer’s authorization?
  • Has the rental company received written notice that payment is ending?
  • Will any charges become the renter’s responsibility after the cutoff?
  • Where and when must the vehicle be returned?
  • Is a written extension available while the insurer reviews additional evidence?

Do not assume that a telephone conversation with the adjuster automatically extends the rental. Ask for the authorization period and any extension in writing. If no extension is confirmed, returning the vehicle by the rental company’s deadline can reduce the risk of additional charges.

The Police Report Does Not Necessarily Settle Fault

A police report can be important, but an insurer may consider other evidence when deciding liability. The adjuster may review driver statements, witness accounts, vehicle damage, photographs, video, road conditions, and the investigating officer’s observations.

Under N.C. Gen. Stat. § 20-166.1, a law enforcement crash report is a public record, and its use in a legal proceeding remains subject to the rules of evidence. An entry or diagram in the report can affect an insurance investigation, but it does not automatically make the adjuster’s fault decision final.

A rear-end impact is significant evidence, but the insurer may still investigate whether either driver’s actions contributed to the collision. North Carolina allows contributory negligence as a defense. If the defense proves that the injured person’s own negligence helped cause the collision, it can create serious problems for the claim. The party asserting that defense generally has the burden of proving it under N.C. Gen. Stat. § 1-139.

Can Rental Costs Still Be Claimed Later?

Possibly. If the other driver is ultimately found legally responsible, reasonable loss-of-use expenses may be part of the property damage claim. For a repairable vehicle, this commonly concerns the reasonable period needed for repairs. If the vehicle is a total loss, the relevant period may involve, if a substitute vehicle is not immediately obtainable, the reasonable time needed to obtain a substitute vehicle.

This does not mean every rental day or every type of rental vehicle must be reimbursed. Liability, the reasonableness of the rental period and rate, repair timing, vehicle availability, and efforts to limit expenses can all matter. Reimbursement is not guaranteed merely because the insurer initially approved the rental.

Before paying personally for a continued rental, the renter may also ask their own insurer whether the applicable policy includes rental reimbursement or another relevant property coverage. Coverage depends on the policy language and claim facts. Using first-party coverage does not necessarily prevent an insurer from later seeking repayment from the responsible party, but deductibles, limits, and other terms may apply.

Steps to Take When the Insurer Ends the Rental

  1. Request the decision in writing. Ask the adjuster to identify the exact end date, the stated reason for ending payment, and what information is causing the fault dispute.
  2. Contact the rental company directly. Confirm when the vehicle must be returned and whether any balance has been assigned to the renter.
  3. Avoid unauthorized rental days. If no one has agreed to pay after the cutoff, additional charges may become the renter’s responsibility.
  4. Correct factual errors promptly. If the crash report contains incorrect contact, vehicle, roadway, or narrative information, gather documents that show the problem. An insurer may consider supplemental evidence even if the original report is not changed.
  5. Preserve evidence of fault and loss of use. Keep photographs, videos, witness information, repair estimates, towing records, rental documents, and communications with both insurers.
  6. Keep receipts. Save rental invoices, transportation receipts, and proof of payment. Documentation may be needed if reasonable expenses are claimed later.

Documents to Gather

  • The complete crash report and any available report attachments.
  • The rental agreement and every extension or authorization.
  • Emails, text messages, and letters from the adjuster.
  • Photographs of vehicle damage and the collision location.
  • Repair estimates, total-loss communications, and repair-status updates.
  • Names and contact information for witnesses.
  • Your own automobile insurance declarations page and relevant claim correspondence.
  • Receipts for rental charges and other transportation expenses.

How This Applies to the Reported Rear-End Collision

Here, the fact that the vehicle was struck from behind may support the individual’s account, but the other driver’s insurer is relying on information it believes appears in the police report. The insurer may therefore end the rental authorization while it continues reviewing fault.

Because the rental was provided to the individual’s child, it is especially important to determine who signed the rental agreement and who will be charged after the insurer’s cutoff. The family should obtain the insurer’s position in writing, confirm the return deadline with the rental company, and collect evidence addressing the specific information in the report. Ending rental payment does not, by itself, establish that the individual caused the collision.

When Wallace Pierce Law May Be Able to Help

Wallace Pierce Law may be able to review the police report, rental documents, vehicle photographs, witness information, and insurance communications to identify why fault is being disputed. The firm may also help present supporting evidence, communicate with the insurer, and document reasonable loss-of-use expenses as part of a North Carolina car accident claim.

An attorney can also examine whether the property damage and bodily injury portions of the claim are being treated separately and whether proposed paperwork contains release language affecting other claims. A review cannot guarantee continued rental authorization or reimbursement, but it can help clarify the available options and the practical risks of ongoing charges.

A path forward

What happened is part of your story. Not the end of it.

A clear plan makes room to heal. We handle the claim. You get back to your life.

Talk through what comes next