Short Answer
You can challenge the insurer’s fault decision by requesting its reasoning in writing, correcting inaccurate statements, and submitting evidence that shows how the accident occurred. The right approach depends on whether you are seeking payment under your own policy or from another driver’s insurer. Because North Carolina’s contributory negligence rule can make disputed fault especially important, preserve the evidence and do not assume the adjuster’s initial decision is final.
First, Find Out What the Insurer Actually Decided
An adjuster’s statement that your parent “may be at fault” is not always a formal claim denial. Ask the adjuster to confirm in writing:
- Whether the insurer has made a final liability decision.
- What facts or statements support that decision.
- Whether the company is denying repairs, rental expenses, or both.
- Whether the decision is based on fault, lack of coverage, a policy exclusion, or another reason.
- When rental authorization will end and what policy term or claim decision supports that date.
This distinction matters. If you made a third-party property-damage claim against another driver’s liability insurer, that company may refuse payment if it concludes its insured was not legally responsible. If you made a claim under your own collision coverage, fault does not necessarily decide whether covered vehicle damage will be paid. The policy language, deductible, covered vehicle, authorized driver status, exclusions, and loss facts may still matter.
Rental reimbursement is also a separate coverage issue. It may be controlled by policy limits, time restrictions, repair status, or the insurer’s liability position. Save the declarations page, rental authorization, reservation details, adjuster emails, and any notice stating when rental payments will stop. A general discussion cannot determine what a particular policy covers.
How to Dispute the Fault Finding
1. Request a written explanation
Send a short written request asking for the precise factual and policy basis for the decision. Identify the claim number, accident date, vehicle, and disputed conclusion. Avoid arguing from memory in a long telephone conversation.
N.C. Gen. Stat. § 58-63-15 identifies claim-handling concerns that include refusing claims without a reasonable investigation and failing to provide a reasonable explanation relating the policy, facts, or law to a denial or compromise offer. The statute does not mean every disagreement with an adjuster is improper, but a written explanation can show what evidence needs to be addressed.
2. Review the parent’s statement carefully
Ask whether the statement was recorded, written, summarized in adjuster notes, or taken through an online form. If possible, request a copy or transcript. Look for incomplete answers, misunderstood questions, estimates presented as certain facts, or omitted context.
If the statement is inaccurate, the parent can provide a concise written correction. The correction should identify the exact point that is wrong, explain why, and attach supporting material when available. It should not guess about speed, distance, timing, or visibility.
3. Submit evidence that addresses the disputed point
A successful challenge usually requires more than saying the adjuster is wrong. Useful evidence may include:
- The North Carolina DMV-349 crash report and any supplemental report.
- Photographs or video showing vehicle positions, impact areas, road markings, signs, signals, visibility, and debris.
- Dash-camera, doorbell-camera, business-surveillance, or traffic-camera footage.
- Names and contact information for independent witnesses.
- Repair estimates, inspection photographs, towing records, and information about hidden vehicle damage.
- Messages exchanged with the other driver or insurer.
- A diagram and a factual timeline prepared while events are still fresh.
A crash report is a useful starting point, but it may be incomplete or based largely on the statements available at the scene. Compare it with photographs, witness accounts, vehicle damage, and any video rather than treating one document as the entire investigation.
4. Ask for supervisor or internal review
After submitting the supporting evidence, ask the insurer to reopen or reconsider the liability decision. Organize the request around the specific disputed issue. For example, identify what evidence shows which vehicle had the right of way, changed lanes, entered an intersection, or failed to yield.
Keep proof of submission and ask for a written response. If the concern involves claim handling rather than only a factual disagreement, a North Carolina Department of Insurance consumer complaint may also be an option. A regulatory complaint is not a lawsuit, does not itself determine civil fault, and should not be treated as extending any legal deadline.
Why North Carolina Fault Rules Matter
North Carolina permits contributory negligence as a defense. In general, if the party raising the defense proves that an injured claimant’s own negligence helped cause the accident, the defense can create serious problems for the bodily-injury claim. Under N.C. Gen. Stat. § 1-139, the party asserting contributory negligence generally bears the burden of proving it.
The analysis should therefore address both what the other driver did wrong and why your car’s driver acted reasonably. When the vehicle owner was not driving, the effect of the driver’s conduct on the owner’s property claim may depend on the legal relationship between the owner and driver, the type of claim, and the policy involved. An insurer’s statement that the driver was at fault does not, by itself, resolve every coverage or ownership issue.
How This Applies When a Parent Was Driving Your Car
Here, the parent’s statement appears to be influencing the insurer’s fault assessment, while repairs and continued rental use may be at risk. The immediate step is to separate three questions: who caused the collision, which policy or insurer is being asked to pay, and what provision controls repairs or rental expenses.
Because the parent’s lawyer is handling only the bodily-injury claim, do not assume that lawyer is also handling the vehicle-damage, rental, or coverage dispute. Ask the lawyer to confirm the scope of representation in writing. Coordination is still important so that statements made in the property claim do not conflict with the bodily-injury claim.
The vehicle owner should also request the insurer’s decision and reasoning in writing, obtain the parent’s statement if available, and gather independent evidence. If the insurer intends to end the rental soon, obtain the cutoff date immediately so the owner can make informed arrangements and document any resulting expenses.
Do Not Let Claim Discussions Replace Deadline Review
Negotiations, reconsideration requests, internal appeals, and insurance complaints do not automatically extend the time to file a lawsuit. N.C. Gen. Stat. § 1-52 provides a three-year period for many North Carolina claims involving injury to a person or damage to personal property, although the correct deadline depends on the claim and facts.
Do not wait until the end of a limitations period to investigate. Video can be overwritten, witnesses may become difficult to locate, and damaged vehicles may be repaired, sold, or destroyed.
Information to Preserve Now
- All insurance policies and declarations pages that may apply.
- The claim number and adjuster’s contact information.
- Written denial, fault, repair, and rental notices.
- The parent’s recorded or written statement, if available.
- The crash report and any supplemental materials.
- Scene and vehicle photographs in their original form.
- Repair estimates, towing bills, storage notices, and rental records.
- Witness names and contact information.
- A log of telephone calls, emails, document submissions, and response dates.
Preserve the vehicle until the insurer has had a reasonable opportunity to inspect it, when practical. If storage charges are accumulating or the vehicle may be disposed of, document the notices and seek prompt guidance rather than allowing costs to grow without a plan.
When Wallace Pierce Law May Be Able to Help
Wallace Pierce Law may be able to review the insurer’s stated reason for assigning fault, compare the parent’s statement with the available physical evidence, and identify whether the dispute concerns liability, first-party coverage, or both. The firm may also help organize a written reconsideration request and evaluate how the property-damage dispute interacts with the related bodily-injury claim.
A review cannot guarantee that the insurer will change its position. It can, however, clarify what evidence is missing, what questions should be directed to the adjuster, whether another insurer may be involved, and what deadlines require attention.