Short Answer
Preserve photographs and video of the manhole, surrounding walkway, lighting, warnings, and nearby identifying marks as soon as possible. Also save witness information, clothing and shoes, medical records, incident reports, and every communication about who owned or maintained the manhole. Because the condition may be repaired quickly and responsibility may be divided among several parties, early documentation and written preservation requests can be important.
Why Evidence From the Scene Matters
An unsecured manhole can be covered, repaired, moved, or marked with a warning shortly after a fall. Once that happens, it may be difficult to show how the area looked when the injury occurred.
Evidence must address more than the existence of an opening. A North Carolina premises liability claim may turn on who controlled the location, who created or knew about the unsafe condition, how long it existed, whether warnings were provided, and whether the person walking there could reasonably have noticed and avoided it.
If it can be done safely and lawfully, preserve the following scene evidence:
- Wide photographs showing the manhole’s location in relation to the apartment complex, sidewalk, parking area, road, buildings, and other landmarks.
- Close photographs of the opening, cover, rim, hinges, fasteners, damage, gaps, and any utility name, logo, number, paint marking, or identification plate.
- Video showing the route taken before the fall and how the opening appears from a pedestrian’s normal approach.
- Images taken under lighting conditions similar to those at the time of the fall, especially if the incident happened after dark.
- Daylight photographs that clearly show the condition and surrounding area.
- Photographs of streetlights, building lights, shadows, vegetation, warning signs, cones, barricades, or the absence of warnings.
- The date, time, weather, and approximate visibility at the scene.
Do not enter the manhole, move its cover, interfere with repairs, or place yourself in danger to collect evidence.
Save Evidence Showing Who Controlled the Manhole
A statement that a private company was responsible is a useful lead, but it does not necessarily identify every person or organization that may have had control over the area. Depending on the records, potentially relevant entities could include the property owner, apartment manager, utility owner, maintenance company, construction contractor, or a government unit.
Preserve the local government’s statement in its original form. If it was made by telephone, write down the date, time, department, telephone number, employee’s name, and the exact substance of the conversation. Follow up in writing and ask:
- Which company owned, installed, inspected, opened, or maintained the manhole?
- What records support that identification?
- Whether the government received earlier complaints or service requests about the location.
- Whether work permits, utility maps, inspection records, repair orders, dispatch notes, photographs, or contractor records exist.
- Whether the condition was reported or repaired after the fall.
Also keep your lease, apartment community map, resident notices, maintenance requests, and messages with the property manager. Records showing who maintained the common area or utility equipment may be important. An attorney can investigate ownership and send written requests asking the relevant organizations to retain records and physical evidence.
Request Video and Locate Witnesses Quickly
Apartment buildings, parking areas, nearby businesses, doorbell systems, traffic equipment, or security systems may have recorded the area. Video is often retained for only a limited period. Promptly identify where cameras were located and note which direction they faced.
A written preservation request may ask an apartment complex, business, contractor, utility, or government office to retain video from a reasonable period before and after the fall. The request may also cover inspection logs, work orders, photographs, complaints, access records, employee communications, and repair documents. Sending a request does not guarantee that records will be produced, but it can place the recipient on notice that relevant evidence should be retained.
Save the names and contact information of anyone who saw the fall, saw the unsecured manhole earlier, reported the condition, or observed workers near it. Record what each person remembers while the details are fresh. Avoid coaching witnesses or asking them to agree with a particular version of events.
Preserve Injury and Loss Documentation
Evidence of the unsafe condition and evidence of the resulting injuries serve different purposes. Even if an initial evaluation reportedly found no broken bone, ongoing calf or knee symptoms should be documented accurately. Follow the instructions of your medical providers and keep:
- Visit summaries, test results, medical records, and itemized bills.
- Prescription and pharmacy records.
- Photographs of bruising, swelling, cuts, or other visible changes over time.
- A dated account of symptoms and how they affect ordinary activities.
- Receipts for injury-related out-of-pocket expenses.
- Work restrictions, missed-work records, wage statements, and employer communications if income was affected.
Keep the shoes and clothing worn during the fall without cleaning, repairing, or discarding them. Photograph their condition and store them separately. They may help address footing, visibility, contamination, or arguments about how the incident happened.
North Carolina Fault Rules Make Visibility Evidence Important
North Carolina allows contributory negligence as a defense. If the defense proves that an injured person’s own negligence helped cause the injury, that can create serious problems for the claim. Under N.C. Gen. Stat. § 1-139, the party raising contributory negligence generally has the burden of proving it.
For a fall after dark, evidence should show both what made the manhole unsafe and why a person using reasonable care may not have seen it. Relevant details can include whether the route was intended for pedestrians, the available lighting, the color and depth of the opening, shadows, warnings, barriers, and whether the condition was visible from the direction of approach.
Write down an accurate account of where you were looking, your walking pace, whether you were carrying anything, and what happened immediately before the fall. Do not guess about facts you do not remember. Avoid posting photographs, conclusions about fault, or descriptions of your physical condition on social media because those statements may later be reviewed in connection with the claim.
How This Applies to a Fall Near an Apartment Complex
For a nighttime fall near an apartment complex, photographs should document the pedestrian route and lighting, not merely the manhole during daylight. Apartment records may help determine whether the opening was in a common area and whether management had received complaints or coordinated utility work.
The local government’s statement about a private company should be preserved, but the company’s identity and actual role still need verification. Records may show that one entity owned the equipment while another opened, inspected, or maintained it. Identifying those roles early can prevent evidence from being lost and notices from being sent to the wrong organization.
Do Not Let Investigation Delay a Potential Claim
N.C. Gen. Stat. § 1-52 provides a three-year period for many North Carolina actions involving injury to a person, but the correct deadline depends on the claim and the parties involved. Claims involving a government entity may also involve different procedures or defenses.
Reporting the fall, requesting records, or discussing the matter with an insurer does not automatically extend the deadline for filing a lawsuit. Evidence can disappear much sooner than any filing deadline, so preservation should begin promptly.
When Wallace Pierce Law May Be Able to Help
Wallace Pierce Law may be able to help investigate which organization owned or controlled the manhole, review property and maintenance records, identify possible contractors or utilities, and prepare requests to preserve video and other evidence. The firm can also evaluate how North Carolina premises liability and contributory negligence rules may affect the available facts.
This process may include organizing photographs, witness information, government communications, apartment records, medical documentation, and loss records. No investigation can guarantee that evidence still exists or that a particular party will be legally responsible, but early review can clarify what information should be pursued.