Short Answer
The claim usually remains pending while the insurance company investigates how the accident happened. The adjuster may review witness accounts, driver statements, the crash report, photographs, vehicle damage, and other evidence before accepting or disputing responsibility. A pending decision is not necessarily a denial, but it does not stop North Carolina lawsuit deadlines from running.
What a Pending Liability Decision Means
When an insurance company says that “liability is pending,” it generally means the adjuster has not decided whether its insured caused the accident. The insurer may believe that important information is missing, that the drivers gave conflicting accounts, or that additional investigation is necessary.
The insurer’s decision is part of its claim-handling process. It is not a court ruling and does not finally determine anyone’s legal rights. The adjuster may eventually accept responsibility, deny the claim, or argue that the injured person’s conduct contributed to the collision.
Until the liability review is complete, the insurer may decline to negotiate or pay the bodily injury claim. Questions involving vehicle repairs, rental expenses, medical-payment coverage, or collision coverage may follow different processes depending on the applicable policies and facts.
Why a Witness’s Account Can Matter
A neutral witness may help clarify disputed facts such as:
- Which driver had the right of way.
- The color of a traffic signal.
- Whether a vehicle changed lanes or crossed the center line.
- Where the vehicles were positioned before impact.
- Whether a driver appeared to be speeding, distracted, or following too closely.
- What the drivers said or did immediately after the collision.
Witness evidence is time-sensitive. Memories can become less precise, contact information can change, vehicles can be repaired, and physical evidence at the scene can disappear. A written or recorded account should therefore be preserved along with the witness’s name, contact information, and the date the statement was obtained.
If a statement was sent to a prior adjuster, sending it again to the current adjuster is a reasonable practical step. The sender should keep the original, retain the delivery email or letter, identify the claim number, and request confirmation that the statement was received and added to the claim file.
What the Insurance Company May Review
A witness statement is often only one part of the investigation. The adjuster may also consider:
- The crash report and any diagram or narrative.
- Statements from the drivers and passengers.
- Scene, roadway, and vehicle photographs.
- Dash-camera, surveillance, or traffic-camera recordings.
- Vehicle damage and points of impact.
- Electronic communications with the insurer.
- Citations, although a citation alone does not resolve civil responsibility.
- Medical documentation addressing whether the collision caused the claimed injuries.
Responsibility and damages are separate issues. Even if an insurer accepts that its driver caused the crash, it may still investigate whether the accident caused the reported injuries and whether the claimed losses are adequately documented.
North Carolina Fault Rules Can Affect the Review
North Carolina allows contributory negligence to be raised as a defense. If the defense proves that an injured person’s own negligence helped cause the accident, that issue can create serious problems for the personal injury claim. Under N.C. Gen. Stat. § 1-139, the party asserting contributory negligence generally has the burden of proving that defense.
For this reason, the evidence should address more than what the other driver did wrong. It should also document why the injured person’s own actions were reasonable. For example, photographs, witness accounts, vehicle locations, and the timing of events may help answer an allegation that the claimant failed to keep a proper lookout or could have avoided the collision.
Practical Steps While Liability Is Pending
- Confirm what the adjuster is waiting for. Ask whether the witness statement is the only missing item or whether the insurer needs additional information.
- Resend important evidence. Include the claim number and request written confirmation of receipt. Do not send away the only copy.
- Preserve the complete claim record. Save emails, letters, claim numbers, adjuster names, photographs, recordings, repair documents, medical bills, visit summaries, and proof of missed work.
- Keep communications accurate and concise. Do not guess about speeds, distances, or events you do not remember. Before giving a recorded statement, consider whether legal guidance would be useful.
- Continue documenting the injury claim. Follow the instructions of your medical providers and keep records of symptoms, appointments, expenses, and work restrictions.
- Track deadlines independently. Do not assume that an open claim or ongoing negotiations preserve the right to file a lawsuit.
Do Not Let the Investigation Cause a Missed Deadline
Many North Carolina personal injury and property-damage actions are subject to a three-year filing period under N.C. Gen. Stat. § 1-52. The precise deadline depends on the claim and its facts, so it should be calculated individually.
Sending documents, waiting for a witness, negotiating with an adjuster, or receiving assurances that the claim is still under review generally does not automatically extend the deadline for filing a lawsuit. If the deadline is approaching, the claimant may need to evaluate legal action before the insurer completes its review.
How This Applies When a Statement Went to a Prior Adjuster
Here, liability remains pending because the current adjuster needs a witness’s account. The claimant’s attorney previously sent that statement, but it may have gone to an earlier adjuster. Resending the statement directly to the current adjuster, with the correct claim number and a request for confirmation, may resolve the missing-document issue.
The attorney can also ask whether the insurer needs anything else and when the file is expected to return to the adjuster for review. That follow-up does not guarantee that responsibility will be accepted, but it can create a clear record showing what was delivered and when.
When Wallace Pierce Law May Be Able to Help
Wallace Pierce Law may be able to communicate with the adjuster, resend and organize the witness evidence, confirm what remains outstanding, and evaluate whether other proof should be preserved. The firm can also review disputed fault issues, help document injuries and losses, monitor relevant deadlines, and explain possible next steps if the insurance company delays or denies its insured’s responsibility.
No attorney can require an insurer to accept liability during the voluntary claim process. If the dispute cannot be resolved, an attorney can discuss whether filing a lawsuit is appropriate under the circumstances.