Short Answer
You can continue negotiating, ask for a written explanation, provide additional supporting evidence, propose mediation, or file a lawsuit if settlement efforts reach an impasse. A representative’s decision to refer your counteroffer to an assigned adjuster does not necessarily mean the insurer rejected it. Keep negotiations in writing, confirm which offers remain open, and protect every applicable North Carolina filing deadline.
A Referral to the Assigned Adjuster May Not Be a Rejection
Insurance representatives do not always have authority to approve a particular settlement amount. If the person who received the counteroffer sent it to the assigned adjuster, the counteroffer may still be under review.
Your attorney can ask the assigned adjuster to confirm:
- When the counteroffer was received.
- Whether the adjuster has authority to respond or must seek approval from a supervisor.
- Whether the insurer needs more records or other information.
- When a written response can reasonably be expected.
- Whether the insurer’s prior offer remains available.
The last point matters because you should not assume an earlier offer is still open after making a counteroffer. Offers may expire, be withdrawn, or be replaced by later proposals. The current status should be confirmed in writing.
Your Main Options After a Counteroffer Is Declined
1. Keep the Current Counteroffer Open
You may allow the insurer additional time to evaluate the counteroffer. This can make sense when the delay results from internal approval requirements rather than a disagreement about the claim.
A written follow-up should identify the claim, restate the proposed terms, and provide a reasonable response date. It should also make clear whether the counteroffer remains open and whether any conditions or expiration date apply. Saving proof that the insurer received the communication can prevent later confusion.
2. Ask Why the Insurer Will Not Accept It
A useful response identifies the points preventing settlement. The disagreement may involve fault, the relationship between the incident and the injuries, medical expenses, lost income, insurance limits, or the amount claimed for pain and suffering.
N.C. Gen. Stat. § 58-63-15 lists failure to promptly provide a reasonable explanation for a denial or compromise offer among North Carolina’s unfair claim settlement practices. That statute does not require an insurer to accept a particular counteroffer, but requesting a clear written explanation can help identify what evidence or legal issue is driving its position.
3. Provide Focused Supporting Information
A counteroffer is usually more useful when it explains why the requested amount is supported. Depending on the claim, relevant information may include:
- Medical records, bills, and visit summaries related to the injuries.
- Documentation of missed work or reduced income.
- Photographs, video, witness information, or an incident report addressing fault.
- Receipts for injury-related out-of-pocket expenses.
- A clear explanation of how the injuries affected ordinary activities.
- Information about unresolved medical balances, reimbursement claims, or liens that may affect the settlement proceeds.
The goal is not simply to repeat the requested amount. It is to connect the counteroffer to reliable evidence about liability, injuries, losses, and available coverage. Documents should be reviewed for accuracy and relevance before they are sent.
4. Revise the Counteroffer or Explore Different Terms
You may choose to revise the amount or another term, but you do not have to lower a counteroffer simply because the insurer declined it. The decision should account for the strength of the evidence, disputed issues, available insurance, expected litigation costs, liens, and the risks of filing suit.
Settlement terms involve more than the payment amount. A proposed release may affect claims against the insured person, other responsible parties, or other insurance coverage. Before accepting an agreement, the release language and any conditions should be reviewed carefully.
5. Consider Mediation
The parties may agree to private mediation before a lawsuit, although neither side is ordinarily required to settle. If a qualifying civil action is filed in superior court, North Carolina law provides for court-ordered mediated settlement conferences. Under N.C. Gen. Stat. § 7A-38.1, mediation uses a neutral person to help the parties explore a voluntary resolution, and people or entities with settlement authority generally must attend when the conference is ordered.
Mediation can create a structured discussion with someone who has authority to negotiate. The mediator does not decide the claim or force either side to accept a proposal.
6. File a Lawsuit Before the Deadline
If negotiation does not resolve the claim, filing a lawsuit may be the next procedural option. A lawsuit moves the dispute into formal litigation, where the parties may exchange evidence, take testimony, file motions, continue settlement discussions, and prepare for trial.
Many North Carolina personal injury actions are subject to a three-year limitations period under N.C. Gen. Stat. § 1-52, but the correct deadline depends on the claim and facts. Shorter periods and special procedures can apply in some matters. Settlement negotiations, unanswered counteroffers, and an adjuster’s request for more time do not automatically extend the deadline for filing suit.
Issues That May Affect the Insurer’s Response
An insurer may evaluate both damages and the risk that its insured will be found legally responsible. If the insurer claims that the injured person helped cause the incident, that issue deserves careful attention. North Carolina permits contributory negligence as a defense, and proof that the claimant’s own negligence contributed to the injury can create a serious obstacle to recovery.
Evidence should therefore address both what the other party did wrong and why the injured person’s conduct was reasonable. A low offer or rejected counteroffer may reflect a fault dispute rather than a disagreement about medical expenses alone.
How This Applies to the Submitted Counteroffer
Based on the stated facts, an attorney submitted a new settlement counteroffer, and the responding representative said that the matter had to be referred to the assigned adjuster. That response appears procedural and should not automatically be treated as a final rejection.
The attorney can confirm receipt with the assigned adjuster, request a response date, and ask whether additional approval is required. If the adjuster declines the counteroffer, the attorney can request the insurer’s reasons, evaluate whether more documentation would address them, and discuss whether continued negotiation, mediation, or litigation fits the claimant’s goals and deadlines.
Meanwhile, the claimant should continue preserving medical records, bills, wage-loss information, receipts, and insurer communications. Any new symptoms or limitations should be documented accurately, and the claimant should follow the instructions of treating medical providers.
When Wallace Pierce Law May Be Able to Help
Wallace Pierce Law may be able to help an unrepresented claimant review the insurer’s position, organize evidence supporting the counteroffer, identify unresolved fault or damages issues, and evaluate whether negotiation or litigation may be appropriate. The firm can also review proposed releases, settlement conditions, medical balances, and possible filing deadlines.
If you already have an attorney, questions about the counteroffer and the insurer’s response should be directed to that attorney. Your lawyer is in the best position to explain the negotiation strategy being used for your claim.