Short Answer
The injured claimant generally has the final authority to approve or reject a personal injury settlement, while the insurance company decides which adjuster, supervisor, or other representative may act for the insurer. An attorney may negotiate and communicate a counteroffer with the client’s authorization, but an insurer representative who lacks settlement authority usually cannot approve it. Referral to the assigned adjuster is a normal step and does not mean the counteroffer has been accepted or rejected.
Who Makes the Decision on the Claimant’s Side?
For a competent adult pursuing a North Carolina personal injury claim, the claimant ordinarily decides whether to accept a settlement. The attorney can evaluate the offer, explain its consequences, recommend a response, and conduct negotiations, but the settlement decision belongs to the client.
Before approving an offer or counteroffer, the claimant should understand the proposed amount, the claims being released, possible medical bills or liens, attorney fees and expenses, and whether any other insurance claim could be affected. Accepting a settlement commonly requires giving up the right to pursue the released parties for additional compensation arising from the injury.
An attorney may submit a counteroffer after receiving the client’s authorization. The scope of that authorization matters. A client might approve one specific counteroffer without authorizing the attorney to accept a later figure proposed by the insurer. Clear communication helps prevent confusion about what the attorney may propose, accept, or reject.
Who Has Authority at the Insurance Company?
The insurer controls authority on its side of the negotiation. The assigned bodily injury adjuster may have authority to resolve a claim within an internal limit. A larger or more complicated counteroffer may require approval from a supervisor, claims manager, committee, or another level within the company.
A customer-service employee, intake representative, temporary handler, or adjuster covering another employee’s files may be able to receive and forward the counteroffer without having authority to decide it. When that person says the proposal must go to the assigned adjuster, the counteroffer is normally still pending.
The assigned adjuster may then:
- Accept the counteroffer if it falls within the adjuster’s authority;
- Reject it on the insurer’s behalf;
- Respond with another proposal;
- Request supporting records or clarification; or
- Ask a supervisor or other decision-maker for additional authority.
An adjuster’s internal authority or claim reserve is not necessarily the insurer’s opinion of the claim’s full value. Insurers may adjust reserves and approval levels as they receive new information. Those internal figures also do not determine what the claimant must accept.
What Happens After a Counteroffer Is Referred?
The assigned adjuster will usually review the claim before responding. Claim handling commonly involves examining coverage, investigating fault, evaluating the claimed injuries and losses, and deciding whether to settle, deny, or continue disputing the claim.
The insurer’s evaluation may change as the file develops. Medical records and bills, proof of missed work, photographs, witness information, prior correspondence, and other documentation may influence the review. If a counteroffer refers to information that the insurer does not have, sending organized supporting documents can make the request easier to evaluate.
The attorney should confirm that the counteroffer reached the correct adjuster and preserve the exact terms, delivery date, response deadline, and any reply. A written record reduces the risk of later disagreement about what was offered or whether a response was timely.
Does a Counteroffer Leave the Previous Offer Open?
Not necessarily. As a general contract principle, making a counteroffer may reject or replace the earlier offer unless the communications or stated terms show otherwise. The claimant should not assume that the insurer’s previous proposal remains available after a new counteroffer is submitted.
The wording matters. A request for clarification is not always a counteroffer, while a proposal changing a material term generally is. The amount, released parties, payment terms, confidentiality language, liens, and scope of the release may all be material. Settlement requires agreement on the applicable terms by people authorized to act for each side.
Information to Preserve During the Review
While waiting for the assigned adjuster’s response, keep copies of:
- The insurer’s earlier offer and all stated conditions;
- The complete counteroffer and proof that it was delivered;
- Emails, letters, text messages, and notes from telephone calls;
- The claim number and names of each insurer representative;
- Medical records, bills, and visit summaries related to the injury;
- Income-loss records and supporting employer information, if relevant;
- Documents concerning health insurance payments, medical liens, or reimbursement claims; and
- Any proposed release, settlement agreement, or payment instructions.
Record whether the counteroffer has an expiration date. If the insurer requests more time, document the request and any response rather than relying only on a telephone conversation.
How This Applies to the Referred Counteroffer
Under the facts described, the attorney submitted a new counteroffer, but the responding representative lacked authority and sent it to the assigned adjuster. That referral is not an approval, rejection, or new offer by itself. The claim remains unresolved unless an authorized person communicates a definite response and the parties agree on the settlement terms.
The attorney can follow up with the assigned adjuster, confirm receipt, identify any deadline attached to the counteroffer, and ask whether additional documentation is needed. The claimant should remain available to discuss any new response because the client generally must authorize the final settlement decision.
Do Negotiations Affect the Lawsuit Deadline?
Settlement discussions generally do not automatically extend the deadline for filing a lawsuit. Many North Carolina personal injury actions are subject to a three-year period under N.C. Gen. Stat. § 1-52, although the correct deadline depends on the claim and its facts.
A pending counteroffer, internal referral, or promise that an adjuster will respond does not by itself protect the claimant from an approaching deadline. The applicable date should be evaluated separately and early.
When Wallace Pierce Law May Be Able to Help
Wallace Pierce Law may be able to review who communicated each proposal, whether the client authorized the counteroffer, what terms remain unresolved, and whether the insurer’s response came from someone with settlement authority. The firm may also help organize supporting documentation, communicate with the assigned adjuster, track deadlines, and review proposed settlement and release language.
This review does not guarantee that an insurer will accept a counteroffer. It can, however, help the claimant understand the status of the negotiation and avoid treating an internal referral as a final decision.