Skip to Content
Wallace Pierce Law Wallace Pierce Law
Call Us Today! 919-887-7892
Top
Pre-Existing Injuries

Understanding Pre-Existing Medical Conditions

One of the most significant issues facing any person who has been injured in an accident is dealing with and navigating the insurance companies’ arguments related to the presence of pre-existing or degenerative medical conditions. As such, a major portion of your energy should be spent exploring your related medical history to help you ascertain what, if any, existing issues may be present in your medical history.

While it may seem unnatural to examine your own medical history, you may be surprised to find that what you have disclosed to your medical providers and physicians often gets lost in translation when being documented in your medical records. For this and many other reasons, it is important to refresh your recollection of your medical history before you ever submit a claim to the insurance company.

Should you choose to hire a personal injury lawyer, your lawyer should spend a significant amount of time questioning you about your medical history. If your lawyer has never asked about your medical history or has not dedicated a sufficient amount of time to this issue, consider asking that lawyer for an explanation. Pre-existing injuries, if handled incorrectly, can severely damage a personal injury claim.

It is important to seriously consider your prior medical history as well as your pre-existing medical conditions, as insurance adjuster routinely request accident victims to provide five to 10 years of prior medical history.

Will a Pre-existing Injury Affect My Personal Injury Case?

When considering your pre-existing conditions, it’s important to remember that an at-fault party is responsible or liable for those a car accident victim’s injuries that were actually caused by the defendant’s negligence. Therefore, if you had a medical condition or injury that existed before the at-fault party’s negligent act occurred, then the defendant bears no responsibility for that pre-existing condition. Put more simply, an at-fault party is not expected or required under the law to compensate you for a pre-existing condition.

To better illustrate this point, imagine that Bertha is walking through the forest when she trips over a hollow log and falls, fracturing her right wrist. Bertha decides against going to the hospital and just goes home instead. The next day, Bertha is driving to the grocery store when Bart runs a red light and collides with Bertha’s car, breaking her left wrist. Bertha sues Bart, alleging that his negligent driving caused fractures to both of her wrists. Since Bart’s negligence did in fact cause the fracture to Bertha’s left wrist, he is liable for that injury. However, since the fracture to Bertha’s right wrist pre-existed Bart’s negligent act, he will not be liable for the injury to her right wrist.

This may seem like a common-sense answer. Of course Bart shouldn’t be held liable for an injury he didn’t cause. In the real world, however, this issue comes up more than you might think, and it gets a lot more complicated when you look at the idea of “pre-existing conditions” in conjunction with the “Eggshell Skull” rule.

The question of whether your pre-existing medical condition will negatively affect your personal injury claim is fairly complex. While most people see it as simply receiving money for their injuries, personal injury law is more akin to a sophisticated and thoughtful negotiation of facts and circumstances to reach a desired result. Given that personal injury involves presenting and arguing the facts and circumstances surrounding the case, pre-existing medical conditions are rarely helpful to a claim. Moreover, pre-existing medical conditions are commonly used as a proverbial legal scapegoating by insurance adjusters to devalue injury claims by arguing that all or most of the medical damages were not caused by the car accident.

Under North Carolina law, each and every car accident victim is entitled to seek fair and adequate compensation for his or her injuries. Under the law, adequate compensation includes medical expenses arising from the accident, pain and suffering, mental suffering, loss of enjoyment of life, loss of earning capacity, and lost wages.

It is important to note that as the plaintiff in any personal injury action, you must be able to prove by a greater weight of the evidence (also known as a preponderance of the evidence) that you incurred or suffered each of your claimed damages. This means that if you negotiate with an insurance adjuster, you must be able to prove each one of your damages by a greater weight of the evidence.

From a practical point of view, your pre-existing injuries, if any, can cause the insurance adjuster to believe that your accident-related injuries were not caused by the accident. It is not uncommon for insurance adjusters to claim that if your injuries were caused by the accident the injuries were just a mere aggravation of the pre-existing injuries.

As such, the best and most effective way to present your personal injury claim is to offer simple, clear, and well-documented evidence of your physical condition both before and after the car accident. While your word and testimony is helpful in supporting your claims, strong supporting documentation from your medical providers can aid in proving your claims and contentions.

Continue Reading Read Less
    “I want to brag about my experience!”
    “When my 4-year old son and I were involved in a terrible head-on collision, I wasn't sure where to turn. Wallace Pierce has been great showing me the way!”
    - Mary P.
    “Richard Dingus is a great attorney!”
    “Richard Dingus is a great attorney! And I think the best, serving in the state of North Carolina. I would recommend him for injury and bodily claim any day.”
    - Isaac B.
    “Thank you again for all you did for my family”
    “They were concerned not only about getting our vehicle replaced, but more importantly my kid’s full recovery.”
    - Coral M.
    “I was completely shocked at the amount I received”
    “I retained this law firm to fight my case. I was completely shocked at the amount I received once the case was won.”
    - Schjuana S.
    “They went above and beyond for me!”
    “Mr. Pierce gave me practical advice and was very thorough in guiding me through the process. I left with a strong and positive impression of him.”
    - Audria L.
    “Very knowledgeable”
    “Was able to either point me in the right direction or answer any questions I had regarding the accident I was in. Thank you!”
    - Steven L.
    “Great Law Firm!”
    “Great Law Firm, Friendly Staff, Amazing Service. Willing to help you every step of the way.”
    - Caleb M.
    “Thanking all of the Attorneys and Staff.”
    “I could not recommend anyone any higher than I recommend Wallace Pierce Law, they get the job done and they do it quicker and better and keep you informed along the way.”
    - Debby L.

featured

Our top priority is to devise customized legal strategies that are tailored to the unique legal needs of our clients, no matter how simple or complicated their situations, might be.

  • $1,900,000 Wrongful Death

    The at-fault driver failed to reduce speed and collided with our client's vehicle. Our client passed away shortly after the collision.

  • $900,000 Wrongful Death

    Our client was thrown from his motorcycle and was pronounced deceased on the scene.

  • $122,000 Car Accident

    Vehicle made a left-hand turn, failing to yield the right of way.

  • $104,000 Serious Injuries

    Client was a passenger in a vehicle that was driving through an intersection when another vehicle ran a stop sign and t-boned the vehicle our client was in.

  • $104,000 Severe Injury

    We were able to not only receive policy limits for our client but were able to negotiate her medical bills and liens to ensure that she was able to keep a good portion of the settlement.

  • $102,000 Serious Injuries

    Elderly client was a passenger in a vehicle that was t-boned in an intersection where a driver failed to yield the right of way.