Accident Q&A series

Can the insurer deny a property damage claim if the collision report suggests I was partly at fault even though the vehicle was stopped with its hazard lights on?

· Wallace Pierce Law

Questions about your claim? Talk directly with a North Carolina injury attorney. Call (919) 313-2737 Send your details

Short Answer

Yes, an insurer can deny a property damage claim based on alleged shared fault, but the denial is not automatically correct or final. In North Carolina, contributory negligence can create a serious barrier if the claimant’s negligence helped cause the collision. Hazard lights support an argument that approaching drivers were warned, but the vehicle’s location, visibility, condition, and reason for stopping also matter.

A Collision Report Does Not Make the Final Fault Decision

An adjuster will often use the collision report as a starting point. The report may identify contributing circumstances, describe the vehicle as stalled, include a diagram, list witness information, and record statements given at the scene. An insurer may rely on those details when deciding whether to accept or deny liability.

However, a report may be incomplete. The investigating officer may not have seen the collision and may have relied on statements from the drivers or witnesses. Important details may also be missing, such as how long the vehicle had been stopped, whether it could be moved safely, whether the hazard lights were visible, and how far away an approaching driver could see it.

Under N.C. Gen. Stat. § 20-166.1, law-enforcement collision reports are public records and may be used in court only as allowed by the evidence rules. A report’s fault notation is therefore not an automatic legal ruling that controls the property damage claim.

Why Hazard Lights Help but Do Not Decide the Claim

Hazard lights are relevant because they may show that the stopped vehicle was providing a warning to approaching traffic. They do not, by themselves, resolve whether the vehicle was lawfully and reasonably stopped.

The insurer may investigate questions such as:

  • Was the vehicle in a travel lane, on a shoulder, or outside the roadway?
  • Was it disabled, and could it have been moved safely?
  • How long had it been stopped before the impact?
  • Were the hazard lights working and visible from the approaching driver’s direction?
  • What were the lighting, weather, road, and traffic conditions?
  • Did the other driver have enough time and distance to see and avoid the vehicle?
  • Were warning triangles, flares, or other warnings available or required for that type of vehicle?

N.C. Gen. Stat. § 20-161 regulates vehicles parked or left standing on highways. Among other things, it addresses vehicles on the main-traveled portion, disabled vehicles, visibility from the shoulder, traffic obstruction, and warning devices for certain commercial vehicles. How the statute applies depends on the roadway, posted speed, vehicle type, and reason the vehicle could not be moved.

At the same time, the approaching driver’s conduct remains important. Evidence may show whether that driver kept a reasonable lookout, controlled speed, responded to visible warnings, and had an opportunity to avoid the stationary vehicle.

How North Carolina Contributory Negligence Affects Property Damage

North Carolina allows contributory negligence as a defense. If the insurer can establish that the property damage claimant’s own negligence helped cause the collision, the insurer may argue that the claim is barred rather than merely reduced by a percentage.

The party raising this defense generally has the burden of proving it under N.C. Gen. Stat. § 1-139. Evidence should therefore address both sides of the event: what the striking driver did and why the stopped vehicle’s driver or owner acted reasonably under the circumstances.

Ownership also matters. The vehicle owner is generally the person presenting the claim for physical damage to the vehicle. If the owner was not driving or controlling the vehicle, an insurer should not simply assume that every alleged act by another person is automatically attributed to the owner. The driver’s relationship to the owner, permission to use the vehicle, and control over the vehicle may require separate analysis.

What to Request If the Insurer Denies the Claim

Ask the adjuster for a written explanation identifying the facts supporting the decision. A useful response can address the insurer’s specific reasoning rather than merely stating that the report is wrong.

The vehicle owner should consider gathering and preserving:

  • The complete collision report, report diagram, and any supplemental report.
  • Photographs or video showing the vehicle’s position, hazard lights, roadway, sight distance, and damage.
  • Dash-camera, nearby security-camera, or traffic-camera footage, if available.
  • Names and contact information for witnesses.
  • Tow records, repair estimates, inspection records, and documents showing why the vehicle stopped.
  • Records concerning the hazard lights or other warning equipment.
  • 911 records, dispatch information, and communications made before or after the collision.
  • The vehicle title or registration and insurance claim correspondence.
  • Rental agreements, receipts, and records showing when the vehicle could not be used.

This evidence should be collected promptly. Video may be overwritten, physical marks can disappear, witnesses’ memories may fade, and a damaged vehicle may be repaired or disposed of before it is fully documented.

Property Damage and Rental Vehicle Issues Are Separate from the Injury Claim

A claim for vehicle damage ordinarily belongs to the vehicle owner, while a bodily injury claim belongs to the injured person. The two claims may arise from the same collision, but they involve different damages and may be handled separately.

For a repairable vehicle, a property claim may include reasonable repair costs and loss of use during a reasonable repair period. The cost of a similar rental vehicle can be relevant to loss of use. Different considerations may apply if the vehicle is treated as a total loss, so the owner should save rental records and all communications about repair time, valuation, and vehicle availability.

If a law firm represents only the injured person’s bodily injury claim, the vehicle owner should not assume that the firm is also communicating with the insurer about repairs, towing, storage, valuation, or rental expenses. The scope of representation should be confirmed in writing.

How This Applies to a Stalled Vehicle with Hazard Lights

Here, the fact that the vehicle was stationary with its hazard lights operating may support the position that the striking driver received a visible warning. The report’s description of the vehicle as stalled may also support the explanation that the stop was caused by a mechanical problem rather than a voluntary decision to obstruct traffic.

Still, more information is needed. The location of the vehicle, whether it could safely be moved, its visibility, the time between the stall and impact, and the approaching driver’s actions may determine whether a shared-fault defense has support. Photographs, witness statements, tow records, and evidence about the hazard lights may be more informative than a coded entry or short narrative in the report.

Because the insurer is communicating with the vehicle owner about property damage and a rental vehicle, the owner should request the liability position in writing and provide any evidence that corrects or adds context to the report. The injured person’s medical and bodily injury issues remain a separate claim. A property damage discussion should not be treated as resolving the injury claim or expanding a law firm’s agreed scope of representation.

Do Not Let Insurance Discussions Hide a Filing Deadline

Many North Carolina claims involving personal injury or vehicle damage are subject to a three-year filing period, although the correct deadline depends on the claim and facts. Negotiations, a pending investigation, rental discussions, or a request that the insurer reconsider a denial do not automatically extend the deadline for filing a lawsuit. Anyone facing a possible deadline should have it evaluated promptly rather than relying on an adjuster’s continuing communications.

When Wallace Pierce Law May Be Able to Help

Wallace Pierce Law may be able to review how the collision report affects the bodily injury claim, identify evidence relevant to the contributory negligence defense, and clarify which issues fall within the firm’s representation. This may include comparing the report with photographs, witness accounts, vehicle records, and the physical circumstances of the stop.

When the vehicle belongs to someone other than the injured client, the firm can also explain the practical distinction between the owner’s property damage communications and the injured person’s bodily injury claim. Any assistance depends on the facts, the parties involved, and the agreed scope of representation.

A path forward

What happened is part of your story. Not the end of it.

A clear plan makes room to heal. We handle the claim. You get back to your life.

Talk through what comes next